top of page

Fear on the Phantom Special: John C Adams Reviews

Book name: Fear on the Phantom Special

Author: Edward Marston

Publisher: Allison and Busby

Format: Print, ebook, audiobook

Genre: Crime fiction

Publication Date: 2019

Star Rating: 5/5

Crime fiction and Halloween are natural bedfellows, so when I came across Fear on the Phantom Special in my local secondhand bookshop I was keen to give it a go.

When I saw that it was set in the Lake District, another favourite haunt of murder mysteries, I was hooked.

Fear on the Phantom Special is one of many crime novels in the Victorian ‘Railway Detective’ Series. However, each story is self-contained.

Wastrel Alexander Piper is keen to enjoy one last hair-raising expedition before settling down to marry Melissa Haslam.

He arranges an excursion on Halloween aboard a local train to the site of a mysterious disappearance.

En route to Hither Wood, close to his home in the Lake District, the train is forced to a stop when the lights go out. A large fire has been lit ahead on the tracks.

Alex is brave, or foolhardy, enough to alight and run towards the flames. He then disappears entirely.

By the time his best friend, Geoffrey Hedley, has rallied the other men to search for him, the fire is under control but Alex is nowhere to be seen.

Exhaustive searches yield nothing. Eventually, Alexander’s uncle Lord Culverhouse pulls some strings down in London to have Inspector Robert Colbeck assigned to the case.

Robert travels north to Kendal by train with Sergeant Victor Leeming. The latter detests rail travel, but Robert loves every moment of their journey.

Arriving in Kendal, Robert and Victor are met by Geoffrey, who helpfully provides them with a list of suspects. They begin to wonder why local policeman Sergeant Bernard Ainsley hasn’t been keener to find Alex.

Eventually, the searches are called off and despite the continuing absence of Alex’s body the investigation assumes the feel of a murder inquiry.

The more that Robert and Victor discover about Alex’s private life the longer that list of suspects grows.

Robert is drawn to Hither Wood, the destination of the ill-fated Halloween excursion. The local blacksmith disappeared there years earlier and his body has never been found even though he was the best friend of the local policeman.

Robert begins to wonder whether the two disappearances are connected.

I enjoyed Fear on the Phantom Special very much. The atmospheric feeling was enhanced by the bookending of the action from Halloween to Bonfire Night. Robert and Victor were likeable and diligent. A side-plot was offered involving Robert’s wife down in London that kept her in view after earlier books in the series.

There were times when I had to remind myself that this was set in the 1860s, as the period detail was only lightly sketched. That didn’t matter too much as it left plenty of space for characterisation, Halloween ambience and plot.

Thank you for reading my review.

Click on this link to buy this book on Kindle from Amazon via affiliate marketing, for which I receive a small commission. Thank you for supporting John C Adams Reviews blog in this way.

You can also buy it as an audiobook by clicking on this link

You can also buy it as a paperback by clicking on this link

If you’ve enjoyed this review, you might like to subscribe to my blog.

If you’ve enjoyed this review, you might be interested in reading other reviews in the Crime category of my blog.

Please consider donating a small amount to John C Adams Reviews if you have enjoyed the reviews and articles you have seen today,

PayPal ButtonPayPal Button
bottom of page